More than one in four American adults have left the faith in
which they were brought up. So says exhaustive research from the Pew Forum on
Religion and Public Life, based on interviews with 35,000 Americans aged 18 and
up.
The survey also found that
Protestantism will soon lose its status as the majority religion. It can
only barely claim it now. Only 51% of religious Americans now declare they are
members of one of the Protestant denominations, a significant drop from the 60%
range 20 years ago.
The new Protestant world looks like this: A little more than
1 in 4 Protestants belongs to an evangelical church. Less than 1 in 5 belongs
to a mainline Protestant Church. In mainline Protestant churches, half are age
50 and older.
The new Catholic world looks like this: Of Catholics age 70
and over, 85% are white. Of Catholics age 30 and under, about half are
Hispanic. Among Catholics, only 40% are age 50 and older — making the Church
slightly younger than society at large, in which 41% are 50 and older.
The survey confirmed some things we thought were true. For
instance, women are more religious. Pew reports that 5.5% of men say they are
atheist or agnostic, more than twice the percentage of women who do.
The survey also taught us some things we didn’t necessarily
know. We may have thought, from the large RCIA classes every year, that
Catholics include more converts than other religions. Not true. The survey said
89% of Catholics were raised Catholic, which is even higher than the percentage
of Jews who were raised Jewish, and about equal to the percentage of Hindus who
were raised Hindu.
Popular belief — fueled by erroneous headlines from the Pew
study — had suggested that Catholics lose more adherents than other religions.
Not true. Only 37% of adults who were raised as Jehovah’s Witnesses still
identify themselves as such. And nearly half of kids raised Buddhist leave the
faith.
But the survey did tally massive losses to the Catholic
Church. Pew noted that, while 31.4% of Americans were raised Catholic, among
adults only 23.9% consider themselves still Catholic. In fact, the survey
calculated that 10% of Americans are lapsed Catholics.
Godspy.com’s editor Angelo Matera pointed out that this area
of the study may misrepresent the true picture a bit.
He cited the headlines that said: “Catholicism has
experienced the greatest net losses as a result of affiliation changes.”
But an analysis of Pew by the Center for Applied Research in
the Apostolate (CARA) at Georgetown University, paints a different picture — in
part by seeing different implications in similar numbers and in part by
avoiding erroneous numbers.
CARA compared the Pew results to its own research conducted
in 2003.
First, CARA drew attention to the fact that the Pew numbers
include a serious methodological flaw. Pew admits that it may have
underestimated the Catholic affiliation of Latinos by a gigantic 10 percentage
points. That’s a lot of Catholics, and could be the reason CARA reported far
fewer Catholics leaving the faith.
Second, CARA made the point that, compared to other
religions, Catholics had the third-best retention rate. Only Jews and Mormons
are more likely to say they retained the faith they were raised with than
Catholics are.
CARA also pointed out that, since the Catholic Church is the
largest single Christian “denomination,” the total numbers of Catholics who
left the Church looks enormous. But in fact, nearly 7 out of 10 of Catholics
who were raised in the faith still claim the faith. That’s still disappointing,
but better. (It’s important to note here that, in both studies, all that
mattered was what someone said he was. The studies don’t take into account
actual Mass attendance.)
Third, CARA’s analysis offered this unexpected tidbit: Most
Catholics who left the Church left before 1988. More surprising still: 1 in 4
Catholics who left the Church left before 1962 — before the Second Vatican
Council, which has been unfairly blamed for Catholic losses.
Matera did notice one other fact, though. “What CARA didn’t
mention in its narrative was a recent trend that leaped off the data table:
23.6% of the lapsed Catholics — almost a fourth — left the Church in the
five-year period just prior to the study, 1998-2002.”
He wonders if this “accelerated defection” not only continued,
but picked up even more speed, in the years after 2002, the year Church
scandals were pounded with relentless ferocity by the press.
At any rate, it’s interesting to look at the numbers to give
ourselves a reality check. Some things we thought were bad aren’t so bad after
all. And some things that ought to be better are simply atrocious.
Two thoughts. First, one thing the numbers show is that it
is ultimately God, not us, who is in charge of the Church. And he keeps his own
counsel about his plans.
The numbers that show we have retained many Catholics
despite the turbulent times in the Church show that the faith isn’t a thin
thread that we are in danger of breaking, but a mighty cord that can withstand
the greatest possible strain. It should be no surprise that Vatican II — which
we know by faith was inspired by the Holy Spirit — more likely staunched an
exodus than precipitated one.
Second, the numbers should remind us that, on this earth,
the Church is perpetually in the same state it has always been in. We are weak
human beings called to a work all out of proportion to our membership’s size
and abilities. Christ is continually saying to us, “Do not be afraid any
longer, little flock, for your Father is pleased to give you the Kingdom.”
Advertisement
Advertisement
Make a Donation now!
Insightful. Informative. Uncompromisingly faithful. The National Catholic Register is more than a newspaper. It’s a cause. Your support for the Register funds important journalism that helps to build a Culture of Life in our nation, and throughout the world. Help us promote the Church’s New Evangelization by donating to the National Catholic Register right now.
.
